Houston and Texas are both 79-80 with three games left, and for once neither team gets to settle this against the other — the season series is done, Houston won it 9-4, and that's exactly the kind of number that decides a division when the loss column can't. Yesterday the Astros had a one-game head start toward clinching outright; both teams won again last night, and it reset right back to a flat tie.
Jacob deGrom starts for Texas at Target Field, where he's been a genuinely different pitcher depending on the road sign — 2.71 ERA at home, 5.35 away, and tonight's game is on the road. The board itself can't agree how to price it: Minnesota's moneyline ranges from -106 to +101 across nine books, a 207-cent spread that means some sportsbooks like deGrom's home number a lot less than others do. Houston counters with Hunter Brown against an Athletics staff that's given the Astros' own bullpen no rest at all — Bryan Abreu and Josh Hader have combined for 76 pitches over the last two nights, in a race with no games left to spare one.
Houston has also quietly lost two center fielders to the injured list this week — Jake Meyers to the 60-day list, Daulton Varsho to the 10-day — with Cristian Javier joining them there too. None of that shows up in a tiebreaker. All of it is what a team looks like fraying at the exact moment it can least afford it.
St. Louis is 23 games back of Milwaukee with nothing left to play for but the rest of the schedule. Its rookie second baseman didn't get that memo. JJ Wetherholt has been worth +24 Outs Above Average this season — fourth-best in the majors, ahead of everyone not named Pete Crow-Armstrong, Bobby Witt Jr., or Andrés Giménez — and tonight he takes that glove up against the best offense he's faced all year.
Milwaukee has baseball's best record for a reason: a 107 wRC+ lineup that scores without needing much luck. But contact quality only turns into runs when the ball finds grass, and St. Louis's infield — Wetherholt included, on a team that grades out at +23 Defensive Runs Saved and +36 Outs Above Average, both top-10 in the sport — has been taking that away from a lot of lineups this month.
Robert Gasser gets a defense behind him tonight that plenty of contending rotations would trade for. Milwaukee's path to October was decided weeks ago; whether St. Louis's infield can make a game that means nothing to the standings interesting anyway is the actual matchup here.
Tampa Bay is buried in the AL East at 96-63, playing out a season that delivered someone else's division. What's still live is whether Freddy Peralta pitches like this version of himself once games start meaning something again. Since September 1 he's allowed three earned runs in 22.2 innings — a 1.19 ERA that's barely a quarter of the number his season line still carries.
His counterpart is moving the opposite direction: Cristopher Sánchez has a 5.84 ERA this month against a 2.93 mark for the year, and he's making that start in a park that ranks among the more reliable home-run yards in the sport. Two starters trending in opposite directions, in a ballpark built to punish whichever one slips first.
The market hasn't fully bought Peralta's turnaround, either — Philadelphia's moneyline has moved from -156 to -174 since the line opened, even with his September number sitting right there. Tampa Bay's bullpen isn't fully rested to bail him out if the market's right about it: Steven Matz and Brody Hopkins have each worked back-to-back days.
Three questions. Answers at the bottom.
3/3 = you're the sharp friend. 0/3 = you're reading the right newsletter.