Three Teams Are Tied at 69-71, All Chasing the Same Wild Card Spot. Tonight, One of Them Plays the Team Sitting In It.
Toronto, Texas, and Baltimore are all sitting at 69-71, all 1.5 games behind Cleveland for the American League's third and final wild card spot — the tightest three-way tie on either league's board. Only one of those three teams gets to do anything about it in person tonight.
Cleveland (70-69) holds the spot Toronto is chasing despite sitting three games back of Chicago in the AL Central race — José Soriano takes a 3.45 ERA into Progressive Field for the Blue Jays, opposite Tanner Bibee, who has authored a tidy 3.88 ERA behind a startling 5-14 record for a Guardians offense that ranks near the bottom of the American League in scoring.
The moneyline splits this game to the cent — Cleveland -110, Toronto -109 — but the run line disagrees with its own moneyline, installing Toronto as the -1.5 favorite anyway. Even one sportsbook can't fully agree with itself about who's better. A game this close on paper is exactly the kind that decides which of three identical records is still playing in October, and which two are watching.