Chris Sale Is Outpitching His Real Numbers by a Full Run. Aaron Nola Is Underpitching His by Almost as Much.
Atlanta leads the NL East by four games. Philadelphia sits comfortably inside the wild card, 3.5 games clear of the cutline. Neither team strictly needs tonight — but the mound matchup puts two of the division's best arms on opposite sides of the same statistical coin.
Sale is 14-9 with a 2.10 ERA, the best mark of any qualified NL starter — but Statcast's contact-quality model says he should be sitting closer to 3.06, a 0.96-run gap that owes more to an 85.8% ground-ball rate, the highest of his career, than to his stuff aging backward. Nola is close to the mirror image: a 4.76 ERA that ranks near the bottom of the rotation, against a 3.95 xERA that has believed in him all year. Over his last five starts the results have started to catch up — 1.80 ERA, 33 strikeouts in 30 innings, 9.9 K/9.
Tonight puts the pitcher who's been better than his ERA against the pitcher who's been better than his ERA deserves, in the same game, with a division lead sitting in the background either way.